Do the innovations brought by Industry 4.0 really make a difference in meeting consumer demands?

Do Industry 4.0 innovations really make a difference to customer needs?

Customers buy outcomes

Reliable products, fair prices, timely delivery and accessible service are benefits customers can assess. The Industry 4.0 name does not itself establish that these benefits exist. In our view, marketing hype begins when a manufacturer's technology is confused with value delivered to customers. New factory dashboards do not automatically improve the customer's product. A consumer using a product at home and a business buying equipment have different requirements; both should evaluate tangible results.

Quality: are defects actually reduced?

Appropriate sensors, a photoelectric sensor checking product presence, or a laser sensor making a suitable measurement can help detect certain production errors. Their presence does not mean every quality problem has been solved. Monitor false rejects, missed defects, returns and rework together. Customers should receive fewer defective products and more reliable operation.

Personalisation: more choices do not always mean more value

PLC recipes, PID process control, and motion systems using a servo motor and encoder can support product variation in suitable applications. Their value depends on producing the variants customers actually need accurately and economically. Choice counts do not measure customer benefit. If unnecessary variety increases setup, inventory and service complexity, the personalisation claim needs examination.

Delivery: visibility and capacity are different

Monitoring downtime through SCADA and recording events with a datalogger can help explain delays. Seeing data does not itself resolve material shortages or bottlenecks. Track order-to-delivery time, on-time delivery and incorrect shipments. More frequent status messages do not amount to earlier delivery.

Industrial customers need actual compatibility

An Ethernet port does not establish compatibility with every application. The RS-485 interface and Modbus protocol are different concepts. Equipment buyers need clear information about protocols, versions, data access, licensing scope and service support. A “4.0 ready” label cannot replace it. Equipment that integrates easily with an existing system and is understood by maintenance staff may deliver more tangible value than an impressive label.

Lower production costs do not guarantee lower selling prices

An inverter drive and appropriate control design can improve energy efficiency in suitable applications. Consumption calculations should correctly distinguish kW from kWh. However, manufacturers' savings do not automatically appear in customer prices. For customers, total cost combines purchase, subscriptions, operation, maintenance and spare parts. The OECD discusses digitalisation opportunities alongside financing, skills and interoperability barriers.

In an illustrative comparison, product A performs the same basic task for TRY 10,000 without a mandatory subscription, while product B costs TRY 9,000 plus a mandatory annual fee of TRY 600. Assuming unchanged prices, B totals TRY 12,000 over five years. Energy, maintenance and the time value of money are excluded. B may provide additional benefits, but its lower purchase price alone does not establish lower overall cost.

Security and privacy belong in the product assessment

For connected consumer products, security and privacy expectations cannot be separated from additional functions. NIST IR 8425 addresses cybersecurity capabilities across the whole consumer IoT product. Buyers should question update support, access management, data protection and clear documentation. Requiring unnecessary data sharing, constant app use or external-service dependence for basic functions can reduce customer value.

Durability and repairability matter

An industrial device's IP protection rating should suit its operating environment; the rating alone does not establish every aspect of durability. Parts availability, repair options and software-support duration also matter. Electronic waste and WEEE become relevant at the end of product life. The Global E-waste Monitor from ITU and UNITAR examines the e-waste challenge. Replacing a functioning product merely to acquire a new label does not itself establish an environmental benefit.

Demonstrate the difference through comparison

Measuring success should also reflect the customer's perspective: fewer defects and returns, better delivery, easier operation or lower overall expenses? Compare similar products, loads and conditions of use. Explain manufacturers' process gains separately from customers' gains. A new system may work well, but “we use Industry 4.0” cannot substitute for evidence that customer needs are being met.

Editor's note: Our criticism concerns selling unproven customer benefits as certainties through “4.0” packaging. If a product becomes more reliable, easier to use or more economical overall, demonstrate those outcomes. An innovation that does not make life easier for the customer may merely have refreshed the product's marketing.