Hi everybody,

Ethernet/IP (Ethernet Industrial Protocol) and Modbus TCP are both industrial communication protocols that utilize Ethernet for data transmission. However, they have distinct differences in their origin, design, functionality, and application. Here's a comparison:

1. Origin and History:

    Ethernet/IP: Developed by Rockwell Automation and maintained by the Open DeviceNet Vendor Association (ODVA). It's based on the Common Industrial Protocol (CIP) and is an extension of DeviceNet and ControlNet.
    Modbus TCP: An extension of the older Modbus RTU/ASCII protocol to work on Ethernet. Developed by Modicon (now Schneider Electric) in the late 1970s.

2. Data Modeling:

    Ethernet/IP: Uses objects to represent data and devices. Each object has attributes and services. This object-oriented approach allows for rich data representation.
    Modbus TCP: Uses a simpler, table-based model where data is stored in discrete coils or registers.

3. Messaging:

    Ethernet/IP: Supports both explicit (request/reply) messaging and implicit (real-time I/O) messaging. It can handle real-time control and information querying simultaneously.
    Modbus TCP: Primarily request/reply based. A client sends a request to a server (often a device), which then responds.

4. Communication Model:

    Ethernet/IP: Supports both peer-to-peer and multicast communication.
    Modbus TCP: Typically operates in a client-server model.

5. Addressing:

    Ethernet/IP: Uses a combination of IP address and CIP path (like a device slot or point) for addressing.
    Modbus TCP: Uses a unit identifier in combination with the IP address. Data is accessed using register or coil addresses.

6. Security:

    Ethernet/IP: Initially lacked built-in security features, but newer adaptations and recommendations focus on integrating security measures, especially in the context of the broader IT infrastructure.
    Modbus TCP: Also lacks built-in security features. Security needs to be provided at the network level, typically using VPNs, firewalls, etc.

7. Complexity and Functionality:

    Ethernet/IP: Generally considered more complex due to its object-oriented nature, but this provides greater functionality and flexibility.
    Modbus TCP: Simpler and easier to implement, making it a popular choice for straightforward applications.

8. Adoption and Application:

    Ethernet/IP: Widely adopted in industries requiring real-time control and data acquisition, such as automotive and discrete manufacturing.
    Modbus TCP: Common in applications where simplicity and ease of integration are paramount. Often found in building automation, solar energy systems, and other sectors.

9. Openness:

    Ethernet/IP: The specifications are maintained by ODVA, and while they are available, there might be licensing or membership requirements.
    Modbus TCP: Truly open and royalty-free. The protocol's specifications are freely available.

In conclusion, while both Ethernet/IP and Modbus TCP are valuable in industrial settings, the best choice depends on the specific application, existing infrastructure, and the desired level of complexity and functionality.

"Platforms established on an Ethernet and Ethernet/IP (TCP) foundation have become increasingly popular in many sectors of industry. This technology, which is both practical and offers time/place savings, has evolved and branched out over time and has been embedded in third-party platforms as well. Below, we have tried to answer some of the main questions we received from our valued visitors about Ethernet/IP (TCP)."

- How does the Ethernet/IP protocol work?
- What are the differences between Ethernet/IP and standard Ethernet?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of Ethernet/IP?
- In which application areas is Ethernet/IP used?
- What security features does Ethernet/IP have?
- With which devices and systems can Ethernet/IP communicate?
- What is the history of Ethernet/IP?
- How is Ethernet/IP configured?
- What software and tools are available for Ethernet/IP?
- What are the differences between Ethernet/IP and Modbus TCP?
- What is known about the bandwidth and latency of Ethernet/IP?
- Which port number is used for the Ethernet/IP protocol?
- Where does Ethernet/IP fit in the OSI model?
- What certifications and standards are applicable to Ethernet/IP?
- How is Ethernet/IP used in industrial automation?
- With which programming languages can development be done for Ethernet/IP?
- What is the potential and future developments for Ethernet/IP?
- How is diagnostic and fault detection performed on Ethernet/IP?
- Which cables and connectors are used at the physical layer for Ethernet/IP?
- What specific security measures exist for Ethernet/IP?

+ What is Ethernet?

+ What is Ethernet/IP? 

+ What is EtherCAT?

+ Back to Automation main page