what is SIL (Safety Integrity Level)?

What is SIL? SIL stands for Safety Integrity Level. It is used in functional safety to specify the required integrity of a particular safety function. SIL should not be understood as a general safety score for an entire machine, plant, PLC or software package.
The fundamental international standard behind the SIL concept is IEC 61508, which deals with the functional safety of electrical, electronic and programmable electronic safety-related systems. IEC 61508 defines four Safety Integrity Levels: SIL 1, SIL 2, SIL 3 and SIL 4. SIL 1 represents the lowest of these four risk-reduction levels and SIL 4 the highest.
SIL is therefore closely related to IEC standards, risk assessment and functional safety engineering rather than ordinary machine control or product quality.
In Simple Terms: What Does SIL Mean?
Imagine that a machine has a special safety function whose only job is to stop something dangerous from happening. A normal PLC can fail, a sensor can break or a wire can be damaged. The safety function must still have a sufficiently low chance of failing when it is needed. SIL tells us how reliable that safety function needs to be. The greater the risk that must be reduced, the higher the required safety integrity may need to be. But this does not mean that every machine should automatically be designed for the highest SIL.
SIL Is Not a Quality Rating for a Device
A common mistake is to treat SIL like a quality class printed on a PLC, drive or sensor. A component that is suitable for SIL 3 applications does not automatically make the complete machine SIL 3.
The complete safety function must be considered. This can include the sensor or emergency-stop device, input modules, safety logic, communications, output devices and the final element that removes or controls the hazard.
A highly capable safety PLC can still be part of an inadequate safety function if the architecture, wiring, diagnostics, actuators or application are incorrect.
What Are SIL 1, SIL 2, SIL 3 and SIL 4?
IEC 61508 defines four discrete Safety Integrity Levels. As the SIL number increases, the required risk reduction increases and the acceptable probability or frequency of a dangerous failure becomes lower.
SIL 1 is the first level and provides the lowest risk reduction of the four IEC 61508 SIL levels.
SIL 2 requires greater safety integrity and a lower probability of dangerous failure than SIL 1.
SIL 3 provides a higher level of required risk reduction and is frequently encountered in documentation for industrial safety PLCs, safety relays, process safety systems and drive-based safety functions.
SIL 4 is the highest Safety Integrity Level defined by IEC 61508. Sector-specific standards may, however, place their own restrictions on which SIL levels are used in a particular application.
Is a Higher SIL Always Better?
No. Functional safety engineering does not begin by choosing the highest possible SIL. It begins by identifying hazards and evaluating risk.
Existing mechanical, electrical and other risk-reduction measures are considered first. The remaining risk is then used to determine what additional safety function is required and how much risk reduction that function must provide.
Specifying a SIL that is unnecessarily high can make a system more complicated and expensive without providing a meaningful benefit. Specifying a SIL that is too low may fail to provide the required risk reduction. The correct objective is therefore the SIL required by the risk assessment.
How Is the Required SIL Determined?
The required SIL cannot be determined simply by looking at a safety-device catalogue. The process starts with a hazard and risk assessment.
The hazardous event, possible consequences, exposure and existing risk-reduction measures are analysed. A safety function can then be specified to reduce the remaining risk to the required level.
Examples of safety functions include closing a valve when dangerous process pressure is detected, stopping hazardous movement when a guard is opened, or preventing a motor drive from producing torque when a safety circuit is activated.
What Are PFDavg and PFH?
SIL is connected to quantitative limits on dangerous failure. The appropriate measure depends on how the safety function operates.
For safety functions operating in low-demand mode, an important measure is PFDavg – Average Probability of Dangerous Failure on Demand. In simple terms, it expresses the average probability that the safety function will fail dangerously when it is requested to operate.
For high-demand or continuous-mode safety functions, dangerous failure frequency is evaluated using a PFH-related measure. As the SIL increases, the permitted dangerous failure probability or frequency becomes progressively lower.
This is why the statement “this is a SIL 3 device” does not provide enough information by itself. The operating mode, complete safety function, failure data, proof-test intervals, architecture and other reliability parameters also matter.
What Are SFF and HFT?
Functional safety does not depend only on a single probability calculation. The architecture of the hardware and its ability to tolerate faults can also be important.
IEC 61508 therefore uses concepts including SFF – Safe Failure Fraction and HFT – Hardware Fault Tolerance when evaluating hardware safety integrity.
HFT does not mean “hardware detected fault tolerance.” It means Hardware Fault Tolerance: the ability of a functional unit to continue performing the required function in the presence of faults or failures, according to the applicable safety architecture and standard.
Are SIL and SIS the Same Thing?
No. SIL and SIS describe completely different things.
SIL – Safety Integrity Level is a safety integrity level. SIS – Safety Instrumented System is an actual safety-related system used particularly in the process industries.
A SIS can use sensors, a logic solver and final elements to detect a dangerous process condition and bring the process to a safe state. One SIS can implement one or more SIFs – Safety Instrumented Functions.
Each SIF can have its own required SIL. For example, one safety function in a chemical process might require SIL 1 while another independent function in the same facility might require SIL 2 or SIL 3.
IEC 61511 is the principal functional-safety standards series for safety instrumented systems in the process industry sector. It is a sector-specific implementation of IEC 61508.
Where Is SIL Used?
SIL is widely used in industrial automation, process control and safety-related electrical, electronic and programmable control systems.
Typical applications can be found in chemical and petrochemical plants, oil and gas facilities, power generation, manufacturing machinery and other installations where failure of a control function could create a significant hazard.
Different industries can use different sector-specific functional-safety standards. In process industries, IEC 61511 is particularly important. In machinery, IEC 62061 and ISO 13849 are widely used alongside the general functional-safety principles originating from IEC 61508.
SIL should therefore not simply be described as an aviation or automotive safety rating. Automotive functional safety uses its own concepts such as ASIL under ISO 26262, while aviation uses different sector-specific assurance processes.
SIL in Variable Frequency Drives and STO
One of the most familiar functional-safety features in modern motor drives is STO – Safe Torque Off. STO is designed to prevent the drive from producing motor torque when the safety function is activated.
Functional-safety requirements for adjustable-speed power drive systems are covered within the IEC 61800 series, particularly IEC 61800-5-2 for functional safety.
Other drive-based safety functions can include SS1, SS2, SOS and additional functions defined within the drive functional-safety framework.
A drive whose STO function is suitable for SIL 3 applications does not automatically make the complete machine SIL 3. The complete safety function from the input device to the final actuator must still be designed and validated.
What Is the Difference Between SIL and PL?
Another term frequently encountered in machinery safety is PL – Performance Level. ISO 13849-1 uses Performance Levels PL a through PL e for safety-related parts of machine control systems.
SIL and PL are not simply two names for exactly the same scale. They are associated with different standards, methods and architectural concepts, even though both are used to describe the reliability and risk-reduction performance of safety-related control functions.
A safety component datasheet may therefore state both a SIL capability and a PL capability when it has been evaluated for use under the relevant standards.
Is SIL a Software Integrity Level?
No, not in the IEC 61508 functional-safety terminology used on this page. SIL means Safety Integrity Level, not Software Integrity Level.
Software is nevertheless an important part of functional safety. IEC 61508-3 contains requirements relating to the software safety lifecycle, including development, verification, validation and techniques intended to control systematic failures.
The important distinction is that SIL is not merely a software score. Functional safety considers hardware, software, systematic failures, architecture, diagnostics, operation, maintenance and the complete safety lifecycle.
What Does SIL 3 on a Safety PLC Mean?
A safety PLC may be designed and certified as suitable for use in safety functions up to a particular SIL under specified conditions. This is valuable information when designing the safety system, but it does not assign that SIL to the complete machine automatically.
Consider an emergency-stop function consisting of an emergency-stop button, safety input, safety PLC, output module and contactor or drive. All of these elements, together with their architecture, diagnostics and wiring, contribute to the performance of that single safety function.
Common SIL Mistakes
“I installed a SIL 3 PLC, so my machine is SIL 3.” This is incorrect. The complete safety function must satisfy the required safety integrity.
“SIL 4 is always the safest and therefore always the best choice.” This is also incorrect. The required SIL is determined from the risk that must be reduced.
“SIL is only about software.” Incorrect. Hardware, software, systematic capability, architecture, diagnostics and lifecycle activities all contribute to functional safety.
“SIS is another SIL level.” Incorrect. SIS is a Safety Instrumented System; SIL is a Safety Integrity Level.
Which Functional Safety Standards Should Be Considered?
IEC 61508 provides the general functional-safety framework for electrical, electronic and programmable electronic safety-related systems.
IEC 61511 applies that framework to safety instrumented systems in the process industry sector. IEC 62061 addresses functional safety of safety-related control systems for machinery. ISO 13849 addresses safety-related parts of machinery control systems, while IEC 61800-5-2 deals specifically with functional-safety requirements for power drive systems.
Which standard should be used depends on the machine, process, equipment and safety function. For the wider subject, see our machinery safety standards and industrial standards guides.
Important: SIL is not just a number printed in a product catalogue. Determining the required SIL begins with risk assessment, while demonstrating the achieved safety integrity requires consideration of the complete safety function, architecture, hardware, software, failure data, testing and operating conditions.
SIL Topic Guide
What Is PFDavg? • SFF & HFT • SIL 1 • SIL 2 • SIL 3 • SIL 4
Related Standards and Automation Guides
Industrial Standards • IEC Standards • IEC 61800 • Machinery Safety • Safe Torque Off (STO)
Industrial Automation • What Is Automation? • PLC & HMI • Device Standards