What is loop gain in servo?

What is servo loop gain tuning?

Balancing fast response with stable motion

In servo systems, gain tuning determines how strongly and how quickly the controller corrects an error between a command and its measured value. The aim is for the servo motor to follow its target promptly and recover from load changes. Good tuning balances following error, overshoot, settling time and stability. Increasing a gain does not increase the motor’s rated power or permitted torque.

Is loop gain the same as a gain parameter?

Loop gain describes the combined dynamic effect around the feedback loop. For a simplified, linear, single-input single-output model, it can be written as L(s) = C(s)G(s)H(s): C represents the controller, G the drive–motor–load dynamics, and H the measurement and feedback path. It has frequency-dependent magnitude and phase; it is not simply one number displayed on the drive.

For a unity-feedback, negative-feedback arrangement, the closed-loop transfer from reference to output is T(s) = L(s) / [1 + L(s)]. It is therefore incorrect to define loop gain generally as “output signal divided by error signal.” Settings such as Kp, Ki or a stiffness level are parameters that change the behavior of the loop.

What do current, velocity and position gains change?

Current loop: Servo current-loop gain concerns how the measured motor current follows its reference. In common field-oriented servo architectures, the torque-producing current component is regulated within these inner loops. Current regulation is usually the fastest layer, with settings established from the motor’s electrical data by the manufacturer or during commissioning. Arbitrarily changing current-loop gains to improve velocity or position response is inappropriate.

Velocity loop: Velocity-loop gain determines the torque/current demand generated in response to a velocity error. Proportional action responds to the present error; integral action helps eliminate persistent velocity error under suitable operating conditions. Many drives use PI control here. Although PID control principles help explain regulation, servo loops do not all use the same PID structure.

Position loop: In a common cascaded architecture, position-loop gain converts position error into a velocity reference. Position control relies on the velocity loop, which relies on current regulation. Inner loops are expected to respond faster than outer loops. Depending on the operating mode, position or velocity control may run in a higher-level motion controller rather than inside the drive.

What happens when the gains are too high or too low?

Low gain can cause sluggish tracking and slow recovery after a load change. Excessive gain can cause overshoot, buzzing, vibration at standstill or sustained oscillation. However, “high gain is unstable and low gain is always stable” is not a universal rule. The outcome also depends on delays, damping, mechanical compliance and gain/phase margins.

Load and transmission calculations directly affect the achievable response. Compliance or backlash in a gearbox, coupling, belt or screw mechanism cannot be removed by gain tuning. Noise in encoder feedback may also appear more strongly in the control output at high gain. A notch filter can attenuate a particular resonance, but its frequency should be measured rather than guessed. Excessive filtering can also introduce phase lag.

A practical tuning sequence

First check the mechanical connections, feedback direction, motor data and motor–drive selection, then back up the existing parameters. Carry out initial movements with limited speed, acceleration and travel, after checking limits and the stopping function. Use the manufacturer’s automatic tuning tool when appropriate. During manual tuning, the velocity loop is generally adjusted before the position loop, after verifying the inner loops; follow the sequence specified for the particular drive.

Change one parameter at a time and record commanded and actual velocity/position, following error and motor current. Increasing gains will not solve an axis that continually reaches its current/torque limit; review torque control, loading and the motion profile together. Stop the test if pronounced oscillation develops and restore the previous stable settings. Validate the final result under the real load, in both directions, using the production motion profile.

A simple position-gain example

Consider an ideal, proportional-only position-control loop with velocity as its output, where velocity demand = Kp × position error. With a position error of 0.10 mm and Kp of 50 s⁻¹, the corrective velocity demand is 5 mm/s. Increasing Kp to 100 s⁻¹ produces 10 mm/s for the same error. This illustrative calculation excludes feedforward and limiting; it does not, by itself, prove that the real axis will settle faster without oscillation.

Command format and acceptance criteria

Using pulse/direction commands or an EtherCAT servo does not determine the correct gains by itself. Command cycle time, trajectory continuity and the device that closes each loop also matter. Velocity and torque control regulate different errors, so the same numerical gain does not produce the same result in every mode. For example, an axis might be required to settle within ±0.05 mm in 100 ms. These are application-specific acceptance criteria, not universal servo requirements.

Related topics

Servo and motion: Servo systems home; Position and motion control home; Velocity control versus position control; Velocity, torque and position modes; How servo systems work.

Supporting topics: Gearboxes; Encoders; PLC systems; AC drives home; PID control.