Does IoT technology cause environmental issues?

Environmental value depends on the whole device lifecycle
Hello, friends. IoT can create environmental burdens, while well-chosen applications can reduce losses of energy, water and materials. The outcome depends on manufacturing, service life, electricity use, maintenance and end-of-life treatment alongside the actual benefit delivered. Adding unnecessary connectivity differs from installing a monitoring system that identifies a significant leak early.
Assessing an Internet of Things system requires looking beyond its sensors. Include batteries, gateways, power supplies, communication infrastructure and the server services used within the assessment boundary. Explain how shared infrastructure is allocated to the application; attributing the entire internet's consumption to one sensor would also be misleading.
1. What does a lifecycle approach change?
Impacts begin with raw-material extraction and continue through manufacturing, transport, use, repair and end-of-life treatment. The Life Cycle Initiative's explanation of environmental lifecycle assessment considers resource use and releases across these stages. An improvement at one stage should not conceal increased burdens elsewhere.
A carbon footprint captures only one dimension. Electricity consumption, greenhouse-gas impacts, water use, resource consumption and hazardous-substance risks are different indicators. Lower kWh does not always mean lower overall environmental impact. Comparing indicators requires an appropriate method and explicit assumptions.
2. Do global e-waste figures refer specifically to IoT?
The ITU and UNITAR Global E-waste Monitor 2024 reports that 62 million tonnes of e-waste were generated worldwide in 2022. Environmentally sound formal collection and recycling were documented for 22.3% by mass. These are 2022 figures covering all electrical and electronic waste, not just IoT devices.
Estimating IoT's contribution requires product categories, device weights, service lives and information about equipment already in place. Adding a small communication module to a meter creates a different material burden from replacing an entire working installation. Presenting the global total as waste caused by IoT is misleading.
3. Why do manufacturing and materials matter?
Circuit boards, semiconductors, metal parts, plastic enclosures and batteries require resources and energy to produce. Impacts depend on the materials, manufacturing processes and product lifespan. Do not assume that every IoT device contains identical hazardous substances in identical quantities. Examine product documentation and material information.
Even a low-power device can have significant manufacturing impacts within its overall assessment. Avoiding premature replacement, extending life through suitable repair and retaining existing equipment therefore deserve consideration. However, keeping an older device is not automatically the best option without comparing the alternatives.
4. How does small power consumption accumulate?
Energy calculation: power (W) × time (hours) / 1,000 = energy (kWh). A device averaging 1 W throughout the year uses approximately 8.76 kWh. Under the same conditions, 1,000 devices use 8,760 kWh annually. This illustrative calculation excludes gateways, power-supply losses and allocated server consumption. For equipment with variable demand, use an appropriately measured average rather than its rated power.
An energy-saving assessment includes standby, connection establishment, measurement and transmission. Connection technology, coverage and retries can affect consumption. Sending little data does not, by itself, demonstrate low system energy use.
5. How do you subtract the system's own consumption?
Consider an illustrative application where annual consumption falls from 10,000 to 9,400 kWh while providing the same service. The initial saving is 600 kWh. If the added devices and gateways average 50 W together, they consume 438 kWh annually. The net operational saving within this boundary is therefore 162 kWh per year.
This is not a full lifecycle assessment: manufacturing, batteries, remote server allocation and end-of-life treatment are excluded. The comparison must also provide the same service. Changes in weather, production volume or operating hours mean that the entire difference cannot automatically be attributed to IoT. Converting electricity savings into carbon savings also requires an appropriate electricity emission factor.
Editor's note: “The device uses only 1 W” does not establish an environmental benefit. Device numbers, useful life and avoided losses must be considered together. Although the example above shows a positive operational saving, environmental payback time or total carbon benefit cannot be established without manufacturing-impact information.
6. What can reduced data transfer and local processing achieve?
Edge computing can produce useful summaries locally and reduce unnecessary transmissions. Its additional processing energy and manufacturing burden still need consideration. Cloud services are not automatically better or worse: workload, infrastructure and allocation matter.
The IEA's 2025 Energy and AI report describes data-centre consumption from servers, storage, networking and cooling. These are not IoT-specific consumption figures. Define the application's required data frequency and retention period; use continuous connectivity and detailed logging where the function requires them.
7. Why can working hardware become unusable?
Physical lifespan and digital support lifespan are different. A sensor may still work when app support, a cloud service or security updates end. Establish the maintenance and update period and which functions survive service closure before purchasing. Keeping an unsupported device indefinitely connected solely to avoid waste does not resolve the loss of security support.
Compatibility, local operation and data export can reduce the need to replace an entire installation. Closed-service dependency and short support periods can cause early replacement, but alleging deliberate planned obsolescence by a particular manufacturer requires evidence. A short lifespan alone does not establish intent.
8. What matters for batteries and repairability?
Battery replacement frequency, spare-part availability and maintenance journeys can change the overall impact. Useful criteria include replaceable batteries, standard connections and documented servicing procedures. A sealed enclosure can improve outdoor durability while making repair harder. Assess environmental sealing and serviceability together.
US EPA guidance states that lithium-ion batteries and devices containing them should not enter household rubbish or mixed recycling bins. Use appropriate separate collection. Follow manufacturer and receiving-facility instructions rather than forcing out an embedded or damaged battery. EPA collection information has a US context; local acceptance conditions require separate verification.
9. Are repair and reuse always sufficient?
Suitable repair can replace a faulty module instead of the entire device. However, retaining highly inefficient equipment, or equipment that cannot be operated securely and safely, can introduce other burdens. Compare repair, refurbishment and replacement over the same service period and function. Include batteries, labour, service travel and subscriptions in long-term costs, while keeping financial and environmental assessments distinct.
Industrial IoT may allow monitoring to be added without replacing an existing machine. Nevertheless, claims of extended machine life or avoided failures need verifiable records. Installing an IoT device does not prove that these benefits occurred.
10. Do RoHS and WEEE mean the same thing?
Within the European Union framework, RoHS restricts certain hazardous substances in electrical and electronic equipment. WEEE addresses matters including separate collection and appropriate treatment of waste equipment. They are not interchangeable “green product certificates”.
RoHS compliance does not establish zero environmental impact or suitability for household disposal. WEEE collection does not imply that every material is recovered without losses. Scope and obligations depend on jurisdiction and product category; EU guidance cannot simply substitute for another country's arrangements.
11. How can environmental claims be tested?
Define the actual need and alternatives first: could the same outcome be achieved without another device? A pilot can track absolute consumption, consumption per service unit, battery replacements, failure rates and device lifespan. Consumption per unit may fall while increased use raises the absolute total; this belongs within an assessment of rebound effects.
Replace vague claims such as “green” or “sustainable” with the indicator improved, the baseline used and the assessment period. Separate assumptions from measurements, and do not treat missing manufacturing data as zero impact. Compare avoided burdens and added system burdens within consistent boundaries.
12. What should happen at the end of use?
Decommission the device safely and address personal information, access keys and account associations. A local reset does not guarantee deletion of cloud records. Consider suitable reuse and verify an authorised collection or treatment route for waste devices and batteries. In Türkiye, consult the municipality, manufacturer or licensed facility about acceptance conditions for household or business waste.
Related guides
Fundamentals and energy: IoT guide, IoT and energy savings and Carbon footprints.
Lifespan and operation: Maintenance and updates, Device compatibility and IoT security.
Waste and future developments: WEEE, RoHS and The future of IoT.
Sources
ITU and UNITAR: Global E-waste Monitor 2024; e-waste data for 2022
Life Cycle Initiative: environmental lifecycle assessment
IEA, Energy and AI, 2025: data-centre energy components; not IoT-specific data
US EPA: electronics reuse, recycling and battery precautions; US context
European Commission: WEEE, separate collection and appropriate treatment; EU scope
European Commission: RoHS and hazardous-substance restrictions; EU scope