Can we harness solar energy beyond photons?

Following solar energy from radiation to useful work

There is much more to using solar energy than installing photovoltaic modules. We can collect heat, harness wind, use flowing water or obtain fuels from biomass. Most of these routes still begin with solar radiation. A photon is a quantum of electromagnetic radiation, including visible, infrared and ultraviolet light. Using solar heat does not, by itself, mean bypassing photons. The useful distinction is between the original energy input and the form of energy delivered by a solar energy system.

Heat is a different output, not a separate incoming resource

When a surface absorbs solar radiation, its internal energy can increase. A collector transfers that energy to water or another fluid for heating, drying or suitable industrial processes. Mirrors can concentrate radiation to achieve higher temperatures; a heat engine can then convert some of that thermal energy into electricity. The conversion equipment changes, but radiation remains the starting point.

For a hot-water application, directly collecting heat and generating electricity to operate a heater are different design options. Required temperature, climate, operating hours and system characteristics determine which fits the task. The useful product does not always have to be electricity.

Wind captures energy after the atmosphere has transformed it

Uneven solar heating helps establish atmospheric pressure patterns. Earth's rotation and the landscape also shape the resulting air movement. A wind turbine extracts energy from that moving air. Its rotor interacts with airflow rather than directly collecting photons. Wind therefore illustrates an indirect solar connection within renewable energy: radiation has helped create a resource available as kinetic energy.

Hydropower draws on the water cycle

Solar energy drives evaporation. Atmospheric transport and precipitation return water to the surface, including catchments at higher elevations. As that water flows downhill, a hydroelectric plant can exploit flow and available head to produce electricity. The turbine receives moving water, not a beam of sunlight. Solar energy nevertheless helps sustain the natural cycle that replenishes the resource.

Biomass carries solar energy in chemical form

Photosynthesis converts light energy into chemical energy. Plant material can later supply heat or be processed into electricity-generating fuels, biogas and other biofuels. Biomass energy thus makes solar-derived energy available in another form and at another time. Work on engineering organisms for biomass production aims to improve parts of this conversion and processing chain. It does not create energy from nothing. Cultivation, transport and processing inputs remain part of the overall balance.

Compare the energy arriving at each device

Technology Resource at the point of use Connection to photons
Solar thermal collector Heat following absorption Solar radiation is absorbed and converted
Wind turbine Moving air An indirect result of uneven solar heating
Natural-flow hydropower Water's potential and kinetic energy Solar energy helps maintain the water cycle
Biomass conversion Chemical energy Photosynthesis stores light-derived energy
Solar-wind spacecraft propulsion Momentum exchange with charged particles Interactions with ions; a research concept

Using collected energy after sunset

Operating without current sunlight is different from producing new energy without photons. Heat collected earlier can be stored in water or another suitable medium; electricity can be stored in batteries. Energy storage separates generation from demand. Solar electricity can also pump water uphill for subsequent generation through a pumped-storage system. Losses mean the electrical energy recovered is less than the electrical energy used for pumping.

Solar-generated electricity can power electrolysis to make hydrogen. In that arrangement hydrogen is an energy carrier, rather than a new unlimited energy source. Conversion and storage losses must be included. For grid integration, the choice between immediate use, storage and conversion into another product depends on the service the energy needs to provide.

The Sun also emits particles that are not photons

The solar wind is a stream of charged particles, not the atmospheric wind that drives a terrestrial turbine. NASA's electric-sail investigations explore momentum exchange with solar-wind ions to provide spacecraft thrust. A propulsion investigation is not evidence of a practical power plant for buildings or electricity grids. Producing motion in space and delivering usable electrical power on Earth are different engineering objectives.

Solar nuclear reactions also produce neutrinos. They interact very weakly with matter and are studied using scientific detectors. Detecting a particle does not establish a useful power output. The existence of solar neutrinos therefore does not substantiate a device advertised as producing energy without sunlight.

Keep gravity and geothermal heat in their own categories

Both the Moon and the Sun contribute to tides; the Moon has the stronger tide-generating influence on Earth. This is a gravitational mechanism, rather than the conversion of absorbed solar radiation. Exploring the connection to tidal forces in space is valid, but tidal electricity should not be described as electricity made from sunlight.

Deep geothermal resources draw on Earth's internal heat. They are distinct from surfaces warmed by sunlight. When comparing geothermal energy with other renewable resources, remember that renewable and solar-derived are different classifications.

Continue exploring

Developments in renewable technologies · Future energy approaches · Advantages of renewable sources · Economic effects of renewable energy · Airborne wind energy collectors

Sources: NASA: infrared radiation · DOE: the origin of wind · EIA: water cycle and hydropower · EIA: biomass · DOE: solar energy and storage · NASA: electric-sail research · NASA: the solar interior and neutrinos